How to choose software for an accounting firm, layer by layer
Choosing software for an accounting firm goes faster in layers: the tax program and ledger first, then one system for clients and work, then only the extras it leaves out. Before you shop, list what you run now; the table of tools by job helps you see which ones overlap.
In what order should an accounting firm choose its software?
Choose the tax software and ledger first, the system for clients and work second, and extras last.
- Tax program and ledger. Staff skills and years of client files are built around them, and firms change them least often.
- The system for clients and work. This choice decides how much following up the firm does every week, so it deserves the longest trial.
- Extras. Add a tool only for a job the main system leaves out.
With Firmary as the second layer, the third list is usually short, because requests, documents, forms, prospects, proposals, e-signatures, invoices and payments are part of it.
How do you map the software stack you already have?
Write one line per tool: the job it does, who logs in (staff, clients or both), what it costs a year, and where its data goes when you leave. Then mark each tool that handles the same job as another one, such as a portal and a file vault both collecting documents.
Mark every tool your clients have to log in to. Those are the ones that cost the most goodwill, and the first candidates to fold into one client app.
What should integration mean when you compare accounting firm software?
Integration should mean data that moves on its own, in a stated direction, without a person copying it. A logo on a partner page is not an integration; ask what moves, which way, and what starts it.
Firmary brings customers and invoices in from QuickBooks Online, copies approved client documents to the configured Google Drive, OneDrive or Dropbox folder, puts client replies to texts sent through the firm’s own phone provider (Allo, Quo, Dialpad, RingCentral or Zoom Phone) on the client’s record, and connects staff mailboxes in Gmail or Outlook with their Google or Microsoft 365 calendars. Its API and webhooks let the firm’s own software read and update records and react to events.
How do you replace several tools without losing a season?
Check the imported records and agree a switchover date in a quiet month. Moving one tool at a time leaves clients juggling old and new logins for months.
Two Firmary tools do the carrying, the Firmary Switch extension for Chrome and Move to Firmary, and they take a firm out of TaxDome, a different practice app, or the spreadsheets it has been living in. They can carry client and contact records, jobs and their recurring schedules, tasks, invoices and payments, logged time and stored documents, depending on what each old tool exposes and how Firmary reads it; conversations with clients stay in the old tool. The whole move waits, staged, until the firm has checked it, no client receives anything, and the tools being retired stay intact. A specialist from Firmary can share the work of the move, and the answers on switching and cost cover timing.
Questions to ask in a demo
- Which of our current tools would this replace, one by one?
- Show me a client approving a draft return and paying an invoice in the same app.
- What exactly comes in from QuickBooks Online, and how often?
- Where do texts from our phone system land?
- Which documents get copied to our Google Drive, OneDrive or Dropbox folder, and when?
- How does a website inquiry become a signed client without retyping?
- When a return is accepted or rejected, where do staff mark it, and how does the client find out?
- What can our own software do through the API and webhooks?
- Can we bring our clients, open jobs and documents in at once, and check them first?
- Who does the move, and how long does the staged import take to review?
A checklist to print
- Every current tool listed with its job and yearly cost
- Tools that clients log in to marked
- Tax program and ledger chosen first
- One system for requests, documents and engagement letters
- Proposals and e-signatures inside that system
- Invoices and online payments on the client record
- QuickBooks Online connection checked with a real client
- Texting through our own phone provider confirmed
- Which stored documents the move can read from each old tool
- Imported data checked before any client sees the change
Request access to Firmary
Leave your work email and we’ll email you the next step.